Posts Tagged ‘data manipulation’

Dr. Jekyll vs. Mr. Hyde – A Perspective Into The Fertility Machine

Monday, March 12th, 2012

Great blog post by a former NYC resident who writes of her experience with two different fertility clinics in New York City

The post describes how they originally chose one clinic, primarily based on success rate data only to have a frustrating, disappointing and costly experience with an uncaring, poorly run clinic. 

After some time off, they started researching alternative clinics and found their Dr. Jekyll (he's the good one :~).

A Better System For Tracking IVF Success

Thursday, June 30th, 2011

Dr. Geoffrey Sher just published an insightful blog post outlining some of the deficiencies in the current SART/CDC IVF success rate model. Specifically he mentions:

  • Currently all data collected is self reported by the member clinics and is not audited by a third party.
  • Spot checks are performed on only approximately 10% of member clinics
  • These spot checks verify the number of live births but do not verify the total number of cycles performed by the clinic. This means that the success rate reported by the clinic still remains unverified. 

Looking beyond Fertility Clinic Success Statistics

Tuesday, March 22nd, 2011

IVF Statistic Manipulation and How to Discover it

Fertility Clinic Success Rates can vary dramatically based on a doctor's approach.Critics of using IVF success statistics like Live Birth Rate Per Transfer as a method of evaluating the quality of a fertility clinic say that statistics can be manipulated. There is no doubt that this is being done. But is the answer really to prohibit comparison?  Isn't it more desirable to expose these manipulations and educate prospective patients on how they can be detected? Many medical professionals would say that most patients are not capable of making this kind of detailed analysis. Really, they say that.